A father once came to me with a question he’d clearly been carrying for a while: “Same parents, same home, same rules. Why do my two daughters respond so differently to everything we do?”

Why children raised by same parents turn out different MagnificImage: Magnific

One daughter seemed to glide through school, structured, self-driven, the kind of child the system was built for. The other struggled with the exact same routines, the same tuition, the same well-intentioned pushing. He wasn’t angry. He was confused. And that confusion is where this story begins.

(Some details in this account have been changed to protect the family’s privacy.)

A Cycle Built on One Word

To understand his family, you have to understand the bigger picture in Singapore. Over the decades, we’ve watched a powerful cycle play out. Low-income families worked hard, prioritised education, and moved into the middle class. Middle-income families then poured resources into enrichment, tuition, and structured pathways, hoping to push their children further up the ladder. When it worked, a new generation of higher middle-class families emerged, and the cycle repeated.

This father’s family was a product of that exact cycle. His own parents had scraped together every dollar for his education, and he’d made it. Naturally, he wanted to give his daughters even more than he’d had.

But there’s a keyword hidden inside that entire cycle, one we rarely stop to examine: “if.” The model only works if the child excels. And when one child doesn’t, that little word starts quietly reshaping how a family sees her.

The Mindset Nobody Questions

Here’s the uncomfortable part: this is rarely about a child not trying hard enough. It’s about a mindset passed down through generations, so deeply rooted that most parents never think to question it. We assume that what worked for one child, or what worked for us, should work for every child. We forget the most basic truth: all kids are different.

When children are young, they often can’t articulate what they actually want. So we step in and decide for them, sometimes without realising we’ve made that call. We focus on the path we believe is “right,” because deep down we’re building a legacy, a version of success we consider ideal and projecting it onto our children.

One of his daughters happened to fit that mould. The other didn’t. Neither outcome had anything to do with how much either child was loved.

The Quiet Cost

Parenting Stress Homework MagnificImage: Magnific

I’ve watched this pattern in families beyond his. Children who don’t fit the expected mould often aren’t equipped to express what they actually feel, especially when they’re young. When their interests get shot down early, directly, or just through the disappointment on a parent’s face, they usually stop bringing them up altogether.

We also forget that children bloom at different times. Some show their strengths early. Others need far more time before their true abilities surface. When we judge too soon based on grades or enrichment-class performance, we risk writing off a late bloomer who simply hasn’t had her moment yet.

Finding Their Default Setting

Girl enjoying art MagnificImage: Magnific

This is why, when I work with families, I use a profiling approach that cross-references several time-tested frameworks, some of them centuries old. Not to predict a child’s future, but to understand their default setting: the natural tendencies they were born with, before school, comparison, and family expectations started shaping them.

When I profiled his two daughters, the picture was striking not because one had more ability than the other, but because they were wired to learn in almost opposite ways.

Armed with that, the father didn’t need to push harder. He needed to push differently, one approach per daughter, each matched to how she was actually built.

Ego Wears a Parent’s Face Too

If we’re honest, the pressure parents put on children rarely comes purely from wanting the best for them. Some of it comes from ego, from how a child’s performance looks to relatives, to friends, to the other parents at pickup. When a child excels, it reflects well on us. When a child struggles, it can feel like a personal failure performed in public.

Most parents never say this out loud. But almost every parent I’ve sat with eventually recognises a version of it in themselves and that recognition, more than any profile, is usually the real turning point.




Every Child Has a Default Setting

Two children raised by the same parents can turn out completely different, not because one tried harder or was loved more, but because they were never given the same starting point to begin with. One child’s natural strengths happened to align with what the family valued and rewarded. The other’s didn’t. Not less potential – unrecognised potential.

If this sounds like your family, if you’ve ever wondered why your children respond so differently to the same parenting, their default setting might hold the answer. I offer profiling sessions for parents who want to understand what truly drives each of their children. Not to compare them. To finally see them clearly.

Bryan Woon is the founder of The Natural Edge, a Singapore-based profiling practice that helps people understand how they’re naturally wired their strengths, their blind spots, and the way they make decisions. He works with professionals, leaders, and parents who want to see the people they love and lead more clearly before deciding how to guide them. His approach grew out of years in the advisory world, watching well-made plans fail because nobody had ever read the person behind them. He believes every person and every child has a default setting worth understanding before the world starts overwriting it.

* * * * *

Looking to reach over 100,000 parents in Singapore? Let us amplify your message! Drop your contact details here, and we’ll reach out to you.

Discover exciting family-friendly events and places to explore! Join our Telegram and Instagram for curated parenting recommendations.